If I could only get
through these last several Caudill nominees for 2014, I might feel home free.
Instead, I am actually rather bored. It feels as though the books have been
chosen, not for their merit as well-written novels, but more for their topics.
Topics hand-picked to let the children experience life through someone who has
it more difficult than the average American 4th-8th
grader, whether the protagonist is foreign or disabled.
Mockingbird belongs to the second
kind of protagonist, disabled. Caitlin is a ten-year-old girl with Asperger’s
Syndrome. That would make for an interesting book in and of itself. It would
join the ranks of the many others that currently line our shelves. It is a
trendy topic and with good reason considering the rising numbers in the Autism
Spectrum. But although Asperger’s is important to the book as a whole, it is
not actually the main focus.
The book was written
in response to the Virginia Tech shootings in April 2007. 33 people were shot
in the author’s “own backyard” according to the Author’s Note. The author
believes that if we could understand each other better, it would go a long way
towards ending the violence. The book would explain what it is like for a child
with Asperger’s to cope with tragedy when they do not show or see feelings the
way other children and even adults do.
Caitlin’s mother died
when she was very young, perhaps a baby. She has been raised by both her father
and her older brother Devon. Devon was instrumental in her upbringing. As a
child himself, he was able to impart to Caitlin, the behaviors that were
considered normal so she could fit into her environment better. But now,
Devon’s gone. There was a shooter at his junior high. A teacher and two
students lost their lives. Devon was one of them.
Caitlin’s father is
lost and depressed and unable to care for Caitlin in the manner that Devon did.
In fact, Caitlin’s dad does more harm than good. In his own sorrow, he covers
up everything that reminds him of Devon. He goes so far as to shut the door to
Devon’s bedroom preventing Caitlin from entering. And Caitlin desperately needs
Devon in any form/manner she can find him. She understands “dead”, but when
asked what she wants, she can only answer with the truth. She wants to spend
time with her brother. Her answers are too complicated for anyone else to
understand.
Caitlin, on her own,
was both intriguing and enlightening. I began to understand how she operated. I
certainly felt for those around her and cringed when she was doing something
that wouldn’t be accepted as normal. But the book was WAY too heavy. When I
first realized that there had been a school shooting in the book, I shook my
head. Too much. Too many bad things and not enough good. Caitlin’s own healing
would have been sufficient. Instead, Caitlin had to somehow heal the mourning
community. And it was simply too much.
An educational book,
certainly. Not anything I would recommend for pleasure – or summer reading.
No comments:
Post a Comment